Amidst
the uncertainty, investors can take chances in Zimbabwe
By
Gilbert Muponda
ZIMBABWE’S
political and economic crisis seems to have reached a decisive phase.
Whilst politicians take time to size each other up as they prepare for
the second round of the “mother of all elections”, this
presents investors with excellent opportunities to take long term positions
on under-priced assets.
The asset class and the magnitude
of the position will require careful and informed analysis. Whilst investors
should take positions, they need to be reminded by one of the first
laws of investment that you only invest what you can afford to lose.
It’s important to respect
this law since investing in Zimbabwe during this period is similar to
a risk arbitrage transaction whereby investors take positions ahead
of a business being restructured anticipating huge upward gains upon
the restructuring exercise succeeding. Should the restructuring fail,
the investor potentially could lose most of their investment.
During this period, investment opportunities spring up on a daily basis
as the market adjusts and re-adjusts with investors struggling to accurately
forecast the likely outcome of the current stalemate. Whilst the politics
plays out, asset prices and asset classes become very difficult to price
as the risk premium becomes virtually impossible to quantify.
The current election season, besides adding newborn babies’ names
such as Runoff Moyo, Independent Ngwenya, Senatorial Gwati, Godfather
Manheru, Candidate Pote, Rigging Hamadziripi, Electoral Commission Ndlovu,
Foreign Observer Chimunda, Puppet Nkiwane, Neck And Neck Nyamadzawo,
Sadhaki Sibanda, Heavy Weight Zviyo, Rural Stronghold Mpala, Polling
Station Mangwiro, Released Results Matongo, Ballot Box and Ballot Paper
Kunonga (twins), will create a new class of millionaires (real dollars).
These alert investors are those who are ready and prepared to take risky
positions whilst others take their time.
Due to rapid currency depreciation, Zimbabwe’s assets are heavily
discounted and represent a bargain when compared to its regional peers.
Whilst some discount is relevant due to high political risk, there are
indications that most asset classes are now trading way below their
replacement cost. This represents buying opportunities for investors
(individual and institutional).
Various assets classes such as listed and unlisted equities, real estate
and stock holdings represent outstanding opportunities as they are likely
to lag behind their replacement costs. Whilst listed equities may be
prone to price controls in the short term, it is clear we may be witnessing
an end of and era and such assets will recover and in most cases, the
upward potential is way higher than the investment holding cost.
It is interesting that a number of companies (manufacturers, bakeries,
trucking firms, etc.) have found that (after some years) their real
estate was in fact worth more than the rest of the business! This has
also been true for many farmers (assuming the title is secure and there
is confirmed long term “letter of present interest “from
government).
This indicates investors
should target those companies or assets that include verifiable real
estate assets on their balance sheets. This is so because even in the
case of a further economic meltdown, such assets will hold their own
and will not only ensure that the investor gets the return of capital
but also the return on their capital.
In addition, should the investor be looking at equities listed or unlisted,
they need to pay particular attention to companies or assets with extremely
good cash management skills. This is important considering that before
the economy normalises, the assets have to be maintained in reasonably
good shape.
Cash management is the difference between profits and bankruptcy during
hyper-inflationary transition period such as the one Zimbabwe is about
to enter. The single fact that influences every decision is: Time eats
money. In addition to investing in companies with solid assets and real
estate, investors should look for assets that exhibit the following
qualities:
- Make absolutely
certain business managers understand the time value of money.
- Never allow your
cash to remain idle (i.e. spin money quick and fast.)
Good cash management can provide a major source of profit, while poor
cash management can destroy a company in a matter of months as it fails
to match working capital needs and fails to cover replacement costs.
- Constantly be
prepared to convert dollars into a stable foreign currency, real assets
or stocks.
- Be aware that
the stock market may become an uncertain source of capital. Even though
companies should now be taking advantage by listing during excess liquidity
periods.
- Be prepared to
maintain more than one set of books.
- Need to be aggressive
with stock management. Inventory valuation should be based on NIFO (next
in first out) rather than LIFO.
- Develop an appropriate
inflationary adjustment for capital replacement or the value of your
capital will disappear.
Whilst the whole Zimbabwe
Stock exchange seems very cheap in terms of replacement cost and regional
peer comparison, there are certain Companies that are more likely to
withstand any further meltdown. These include Old Mutual, AFRE Corporation,
ZPI, Pearl Holdings, Dawn Properties and Mash Holdings. These are companies
with solid asset base and generate strong cash flows.
In addition, asset rich companies
such as ZECO Holdings represent excellent value given that they own
so much real estate which is fully paid for. There are opportunities
to further unlock more wealth from ZECO Holdings by separately listing
the Real Estate owning division. Further balance sheet restructuring
for ZECO Holdings and other similar companies represent opportunities
for those investors who have a medium to long term view of the market.
These stocks have potential to wither a storm and offer remarkable upside
should the good times start to roll.
DISCLAIMER
The views expressed are personal and are subject to change based on
market and other conditions. The opinions expressed may differ from
those with different investment philosophies. The information provided
does not constitute investment advice and it should not be relied on
as such. There is no representation nor warranty as to the current accuracy
of, nor liability for, decisions based on such information. Investing
in shares may not be suitable for all investors. Seek independent advice
if necessary. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
Gilbert Muponda
is a Zimbabwe-born entrepreneur, exiled in Canada. He can be contacted
at gilbert@gilbertmuponda.com.
See his website: www.gilbertmuponda.com
JOIN
THE DEBATE ON THIS ARTICLE ON THE NEWZIMBABWE.COM FORUMS
newsdesk@newzimbabwe.com